Pimping v. Trafficking - Consequences for Victims

October 07, 2015 Mariah Long Story 
Sex Trafficking, Prosecution, Women & Girls

In December of 2014, we had the privilege of visiting and aftercare shelter called Open Door Foundation. Mirela is a lawyer for the foundation and is working on a variety of cases at all times. While talking about the inner workings of a trafficking case, she brought up that it is incredibly difficult to get a trafficking conviction; so, most prosecutors will avoid it. This challenge has major implications for the victims.

©End Slavery Now

Trafficking or Pimping

Since a trafficking charge is so hard to prove, most prosecutors will opt for bringing a pimping charge against the trafficker. A conviction on a pimping charge has the same amount of jail time and is an easier conviction. So, for the sake of getting the conviction, this route is often taken. However, the difference in outcomes for a victim is huge.

A Pimping Conviction Makes You a Prostitute

If the conviction was for trafficking, that would mean those harmed would be considered victims by everyone involved. But whenever the conviction is for pimping, that means those harmed were prostitutes. This framing could have dire consequences for one of Mirela's clients. For example, one of her clients was trafficked for two years, and during that time her husband divorced her. When she was rescued she fought to have custody of her children. Mirela knows that if her client's trafficker gets convicted of pimping this will likely mean that her client will not see her children again. The state will see her as a prostitute and deem her unfit to be a mother. If they choose to prosecute for trafficking, however, this victim would be seen as a victim and would have a much better chance of regaining custody of her children. So, while trafficking convictions are hard to get, Mirela believes that lawyers have to start trying for those convictions for the sake of the victims.

Whenever laws are made and indictments are carried out, lawyers must have the lives of the victims in mind. There is more at stake than a conviction rate.

Topics: Sex Trafficking, Prosecution, Women & Girls

About the Author

Mariah Long

Mariah was previously the Program Manager of End Slavery Now. She graduated from the University of Cincinnati's DAAP program with a degree in Digital Design. 

Related Actions

Urge the Ohio Senate to Protect All Minor Trafficking Victims

HB 461 would bring Ohio law into compliance with federal law regarding trafficking victims aged 16 and 17.

Learn about #MMIWG on Indigenous Peoples' Day

The intersection of gender-based violence and MMIWG is heavily intertwined. It is important to understand the connection between domestic, dating, and sexual violence and the high incidence of missing and murdered Indigenous women and girls (MMIWG) in the United States.